Of all the things to be concerned about in the world, some former Northwestern professor has attacked Dr. Jill Biden, who has a doctoral degree in education, for having the presumption to refer to herself as “Dr.” Jill Biden. Dr. Joseph Epstein (we added the Dr.) actually does have some academic chops, which makes his desire to create a controversy so he can get another 15 minutes of fame somewhat curious. He’s been surrounded his whole working life by academics who call themselves “Dr.s”, but suddenly it’s a problem meriting a Wall Street Journal op-ed piece. Our father, 30 years a college professor, also used “Dr.” and didn’t seem to suffer any ill effects, nor did anyone else of which we are aware.
Dr. Epstein says only medical doctors should be allowed to use the title, never mind the years of work and sweat that go into earning a doctoral degree. This fellow should know, but apparently doesn’t, that credentials matter, especially in snooty and elitist academia. And people who earn a doctorate should rightly be proud of their achievement.
Surpisingly, the Associated Press “stylebook” agrees with Epstein and plainly states that:
“Use Dr. in first reference as a formal title before the name of an individual who holds a doctor of dental surgery, doctor of medicine, doctor of optometry, doctor of osteopathic medicine, doctor of podiatric medicine, or doctor of veterinary medicine. . . . .Do not use Dr. before the names of individuals who hold other types of doctoral degrees.”
In this world of hims are thems or hers or nongendered, and hers are thems or hims or nongendered, and the media being willing to call any egotist just about whatever they decide they want to be called (for example, “the artist formerly known as Prince” – c’mon), it is particularly surprising that the AP here is willing to make an editorial judgement about the value of a hard-earned Ph.D degree. And that value judgment apparently is that it has no value, so even if you have a doctorate you can’t call yourself a Dr.
The hypocrisy here is redolent with media elitism (or more accurately, the media’s intellectual inferiority complex, which is well earned, by the way), since it exceedingly rare to find a so-called “journalist” that has a doctorate. “Those that can’t do, teach” is the rule apparently.
We are willing to call Dr. Epstein a Dr., whether he likes it or not, he earned it, though there are lots of other things we could call him. Narcissist comes to mind, as if anyone really gives a hoot what he thinks about anything. If he doesn’t want to be a Dr., then fine, but his attempt to undermine the value of a higher degree is insulting to his colleagues and everyone else who thinks getting a doctorate is an actual achievement. But to raise this sort of a phony issue in an attempt to get himself into the news does nothing but show how big a jerk he is.
Let’s abbreviate “jerk” to “Jk.” So he can be Jk. Epstein going forward. He’s earned it.